Friday, February 19, 2010

Riddles About the Universe

In an attempt to explain the origin of the universe, astronomers once held that the cosmos had always existed and that matter was constantly coming into being. This was known as the Steady State Theory. Eventually, this principle was refuted and replaced by the "Big Bang" Theory, which based on strong evidence, shows that that the universe has not existed eternally after all and in fact was "born" about 13.5 billion years ago.

If you think about it, Steady State harmonizes with the concept of a God--a universe as timeless as the eternal supreme being who created it. Such is not the case with the Big Bang. If a beginning point in time has been established, the very existence of this point of origin for physical matter and energy means that there was nothing--not even space or time (an almost unimaginable concept) before the instant that the first particle flared into existence.

Obviously time is a measurable dimension and began at the instant that the universe popped into existence. One question that comes to mind (well mine anyway) is why did this event happen at the particular moment that it did, i. e. why 13 billion years ago? Why not 20 billion or 11 billion? In other words, why did God pick that particular time to start the ball rolling? What was he doing before then?

In addition there are so many contingencies after the birth of the universe that had to happen for physical matter to evolve and coalesce into galaxies which in turn are composed of stars one of which had the right characteristics to allow the formation of our planet. In turn, our world had to have just the right balance of chemical elements--and even a moon of the right size and distance for life as we know it to begin here. Then over eons, that life evolved from primordial soup to humans--and everything in between.

The intricacy of all these events is so staggering that (as Richard Dawkins points out in The God Delusion) for all this to have happened as the result of creation by a god who would have had to be even more complex than the universe and its laws does not make sense. One reason is the "first cause" conundrum. If God created the universe, who created God? It's not satisfactory to say that "he" has always been "there." Where was "there" if nothing existed prior Big Bang?

But back to the question as to why Big Bang occurred 13 billion years ago, for that matter why did it happen at all? Science has offered various conjectures. One of these is that Big Bang and the resulting formation of our universe was the result of a disturbance in a larger metaverse, and there may be an infinite number of other universes in other dimensions that were born in a similar manner.


In the distant future Earth will eventually become uninhabitable as the sun follows the typical life cycle of other stars. The sun's heat and size will grow to the point that Earth will be obliterated. By that time, humankind (assuming that we have not annihilated ourselves in the meantime)--or whatever we will have evolved into-- will have likely colonized other star systems. But the problem is nothing lasts forever, and that includes the cosmos. According to cosmological predictions, eventually, the universe itself will also come to an end in one of two ways.

Since the time of the Big Bang, the universe has been expanding. Eventually, this expansion may reverse itself, and the universe will collapse in on itself in the "Big Crunch". There is even speculation that the Big Bang, expansion, and Big Crunch have happened in the distant past and will repeat themselves in a never ending cycle.

The other possible finale will be an endless expansion and dissolution of the cosmos into infinity as every galaxy pulls further apart from each other, unravels, and every star eventually dies out. So just as it had a beginning, the universe will at some point have an end. Thus the cosmos carries within it the seeds of its own destruction, either with a bang or a whimper. This leads to the question why would God create the universe only to ultimately destroy it?

Through experiments that simulate the Big Bang, cosmology is bringing us closer to understanding the details of how universe began. But will it ever be able to explain the reason that out of what had been eternal nothingness, in a split second came the the beginning of everything that ever has been or ever will exist?

For a more expansive and articulate discussion than I could ever present on the questions raised in this post, I recommend the book Fabric of the Cosmos by Brian Greene.


Anonymous said...

Some things we will not know, at least in my lifetime. Carl Sagan once suggested that the purpose of the universe was to produce rocks, because it was very good at that.

We'd have to get too deep into the philosophy of language (at least this late at night), but a lot of those "why?" questions (why is there something rather than nothing?) are meaningless from a linguistic perspective.

Anonymous said...

PS. Did you know that one of the Google ads that appears on your site is "6 Reasons to Believe"?

Secular Guy said...

Hi Anonymous,

Thanks for your thoughts. I agree that we'll probably not discover the answers to my some of my queries in our lifetime--if ever. But such questions are fun to posit anyway, especially the ones that challenge theistic b.s. that is so prevalent in American society.

As for the Google ads, I appreciate your concern. The problem is that I've not yet perfected the art of Adsense filtering.

Anonymous said...

The question "If God created the yniverse, then who created God?" has been answered in an article published in the online journal Scientific God Journal Volume 1, Issue 8 (
H. S. Pal

Secular Guy said...


Thanks for your comment. I always appreciate it when readers care enough about my site to dig in to the archived posts.

The home page of "Scientific God" does indeed state "....we hope that one day we will be able to answer scientifically the questions concerning us the most - who are we, where did we come from, where are we going, and, is there a Scientific GOD?"

The actual contents of "Volume 1, Issue 8 are not displayed on line. If in fact SG has resolved the issue of "If God created the universe, who created God", briefly what is their answer? And why hasn't a resolution so profound been more publicized?

IMO "Scientific" and "God" are mutually exclusive terms. BTW if "God" has been "discovered", which deity is it? One of the major Western faiths or from an Eastern religion? Why has (s)he not confirmed his / her existence with a press release?